ID TEST: ADVICE AND
EXAMPLES
Remember, your job on
the test is to convince me you've done all the reading. So be sure
to use the core list to refer to as many works as possible. Be specific;
put in any details that you can remember that will show that you
read and retained the material. Try to bring in at least two or three
works for each ID. You only have five of them to cover the whole course
so far. Don't BS-- remember I don't care so much if you are right
or if I agree with you; I want to know if you have read the assignments.
BASIC ELEMENTS OF A GOOD
ID ANSWER:
-
Identify the author, term,
type of criticism: what are they famous for? When did they happen?
What articles did we read associated with them?
-
Give a couple of examples drawn
from the reading
-
Tie it into the rest of the
course -- how does this fit into the history of feminist criticism?
What other articles have we read with similar ideas?
SAMPLE:
-
(TERM) The Idea of the Other--
comes from Simone de Beavoir's The Second Sex. Refers to the
idea that all humans in groups define themselves against outsiders.
Those people represent all the aspects of being human that the core group
has trouble dealing with. In particular, DeB says that Woman is Other
for western culture. Men project all their fears on her: woman is
emotional; woman is dumb; women is crafty and manipulative etc. The idea
of the Other helps understand many archetypes in feminist archetypal criticism.
The Other that accompanies male hero is often a projection of the Shadow,
the Jungian idea of all the parts of ourselves that we repress. Virginia
Woolf deals with this idea alaso in the 2nd chapter of Room where
she talks about all the different ways that women appear in fiction, how
they are always so powerful, but then in reality they are "beaten and flung
about the room." Ellmann also in her discussion of the wild steroetypes
used to describe women writers deals with othering; she says women writers
are always seen in terms of their bodies, and books are described in physical
terms.
-
(CRITIC) M.H. Abrams
is the critic who did the chart of the four orientations of critical theory.
The chart came from a book called The Mirror and the Lamp.
He divides the world of criticism into four arenas:
-
the WORLd -- Mimetic criticism
that deals with how art reproduces reality
-
AUDIENCE -- Rhetorical criticism
that deals with how people read
-
THE AUTHOR -- Expressive crit
that deals with the creative process
-
THE WORK -- Objective crit
which deals just with the text.
According to Abrams, the history
of lit crit moves from mimetic to rhetroical to expressive to objective.
We can see this same movement in the hsitory of feminist criticism .
The first stage of feminist criticism, CRITIQUE, is focused on images of
women: telling how bad all the stereotypes are, as well as discussing how
women readers feel when they read these stereotypes. Ellman show
a lot of these steroetypes-- women as balloons, light headed, etc.
Nina Baym talks about how the Myth of the great American novel excludes
women beacuse they are seterotyped as socially repressive. Judith
Fetterly's "Politics of Reading" is a full account of how women readers
of American literature have to read against themselves, to see themselves
as the enemy, as evil or unpleasant, or dead.