Cultivar
Differences in Rough Bluegrass Germination Occur with Increased Salinity
James
J. Camberato, S. Bruce Martin, and Amy V. Turner
Clemson
University, Pee Dee Research and Education Center
Rough bluegrass (Poa trivialis)
is frequently used to overseed golf course greens in coastal areas of the
Carolinas where irrigation water can be saline (high in salts). Salinity slows
the germination of bentgrass, ryegrass, and tall fescue as well as other
grasses. Within a type of grass there are also cultivar differences in
sensitivity to salinity--the germination of some cultivars is minimally
affected by salinity, whereas that of others is seriously reduced. Our
previous work with rough bluegrass, in the absence of salinity, established
substantial differences in germination among cultivars, as well as among seed
lots of the same cultivar (Carolinas Green, May-June 1999). In view of this
earlier research we wanted to determine the effects of salinity on rough
bluegrass and the extent of cultivar/seed lot variation in salinity
sensitivity. To obtain this information, we exposed 14 cultivars/seed lots of
rough bluegrass to different levels of salinity (0, 1.8, 3.4, and 5.0 dS/m or
mmhos/cm) under controlled conditions and quantified germination.
Materials
and Methods
Seed from ten rough bluegrass cultivars/seed lots was collected in
October and November, 1999 from golf course superintendents who had purchased
commercially available seed. Seed from four cultivars (#3, #5, #9, and #13)
was collected from commercially available seed the previous year. Cultivar/seed
lot information is listed in Table 1.
Fifty seed of each cultivar were placed on pre-moistened germination
paper in petri dishes and then sealed with parafilm. Moistening solutions
differed in salinity— 0, 1.8, 3.4, and 5.0 dS/m
or mmhos/cm established with NaCl at 0.88, 1.75, and 2.63 g L-1.
These levels of salinity correspond to 0, 1150, 2175, and 3200 ppm or mg/L.
Petri dishes were placed in growth chambers with 12 h of light at 68 oF
and 12 h of darkness at 50 oF. These conditions are ideal for rough
bluegrass germination.
Salinity effects and cultivar differences in rapidity of germination
were assessed by determining germination 6 days after seeding (DAS). Total
germination was determined at 17 DAS. Earlier studies showed that germination
of rough bluegrass at this temperature regime was essentially complete at 17
DAS. Seed was considered germinated if both a shoot and root were visible to
the eye with a magnifying lens.
Experimental design was split block with salinity level as the main
block and cultivar randomized within salinity level. There were nine
replications of each treatment. Analysis of variance was used to identify
treatment differences.
|
Table
1. Cultivar identification number and reported germination for 14
differing rough bluegrass cultivars and seed lots. |
|||
|
# |
Cultivar |
Tag
Identification |
Reported
Germination % |
|
1 |
Cypress |
J5-9-CY8-300-1 |
90 |
|
2 |
Cypress |
J5-9-CY8-299 |
85 |
|
3 |
Cypress |
J11-8-CY5-228 |
90 |
|
4 |
Laser |
J68-9-LA-663 |
85 |
|
5 |
Laser |
J6-8-LA-629 |
NA |
|
6 |
Fuzzy |
J6-9-238 |
85 |
|
7 |
Fuzzy |
J6-8-21 |
85 |
|
8 |
Sabre
II |
J6-8-ST820 |
85 |
|
9 |
Sabre
II |
J6-7-ST598 |
90 |
|
10 |
Pro-Am |
J7-9-PA05 |
NA |
|
11 |
Darkhorse |
J5-9-DH6-253-1 |
85 |
|
12 |
Winterplay |
J6-8-WP33 |
90 |
|
13
|
Winterplay |
J7-8-WP70 |
92 |
|
14 |
Bariviera |
J7-8-PT-477 |
85 |
|
NA
= not available. |
|||
Results
There were substantial differences in early germination among the
cultivars and seed lots (Fig. 1). The most rapid cultivar/seed lot examined
was Laser (#4, #5). Germination was 65-70% at 6 days after seeding (DAS) for
the two seed lots of this cultivar at a salinity level of 0 dS/m. The slowest
cultivar/seed lot in this study was a seed lot of Winterplay (#13) that had
18% germination at this same time. However, differences in early germination
among seed lots of the same cultivar were just as great as between cultivars.
For example, the other Winterplay seed lot (#12) had twice the
germination at 6 DAS, as the slowest germinating Winterplay seed lot
(#13). Similarly, the three seed lots of Cypress (#1-3), ranged in
germination at 6 DAS from 34 to 60% in the no salinity treatment.
Salinity reduced early germination of all cultivars, and each level of
salinity slowed germination (Fig. 1). The salinity levels used in this study,
1.8, 3.4, or 5.0 dS/m, were chosen to simulate the use of poor quality
irrigation water with salinity levels in the 0.8 to 2 dS/m range. With
evaporation of water at the soil surface, salinity levels of the moisture
surrounding the seed is likely to be two to three times that in the irrigation
water.
Fig. 1. Effect of four levels of
salinity on germination of 14 rough bluegrass
cultivars
at 6 days after seeding (DAS).
The effect of salinity on germination at 6 DAS was cultivar/seed lot
dependent (Fig. 1). To illustrate which cultivars/seed lots were most and least
affected by salinity, the germination index was calculated by dividing
germination at 5.0 dS/m by germination at 0 dS/m (Fig. 2). A germination index
of 1.0 indicates germination was just as rapid at 5.0 dS/m as at 0 dS/m.
Eleven of 14 cultivars/seed lots examined had germination indexes between
0.36 and 0.63, meaning early germination at 5.0 dS/m was about half that at 0 dS/m.
Two cultivars, Laser (#5) and Fuzzy (#7), were slightly more tolerant to
salinity than average, with germination indexes of 0.70 or better. The other
seed lots of these two cultivars (Laser #4 and Fuzzy #6) were just average in
salinity tolerance, another example of how variable cultivar characteristics
with respect to germination can be from seed lot to seed lot. One cultivar/seed
lot, Winterplay (#13) was extremely salinity sensitive with a germination index
of 0.17. Seed lot variability in early germination sensitivity to salinity was
obvious with this cultivar as well. The germination index of the other
Winterplay seed lot (#12) was average at 0.41.
Although salinity delayed germination it did not have much effect on
final germination. Final germination percentage, ranged from 92% with salinity
levels of 0, 1.8, or 3.4 dS/m to 90% at 5.0 dS/m.

Fig. 2. Germination index of 14 rough bluegrass cultivars at 6 days after
seeding at the highest salinity level, 5.0 dS/m. Germination index is
germination at 5.0 dS/m divided by germination at 0 dS/m. The germination index
is an indicator of the relative effect of salinity on germination; a value of
1.0 indicates germination was just as rapid at 5.0 dS/m as at 0 dS/m.
Conclusions
For rough bluegrass, differences in germination rate and in sensitivity
to salinity were highly cultivar/seed lot dependent. Earlier work showed cold
sensitivity also to be cultivar/seed lot dependent. Slow germination due to
cultivar/seed lot performance, salinity, and cold temperature will slow
establishment of rough bluegrass on bermudagrass greens. In our earlier work
with cold sensitivity we found that germination percentage in the field was
about half that found under controlled conditions. Consequently, differences in
germination among cultivar/seed lots and due to salinity will likely be greater
in the field than under controlled conditions.
To avoid problems due to a poor performing or extremely salinity or cold
sensitive cultivar/seed lot we suggest overseeding with several rough bluegrass
cultivars and seed lots. Blends of cultivars and seed lots are increasingly
being sold by seed companies and are convenient to use. Alternatively,
superintendents are purchasing several different cultivars and mixing them as
they are seeded. We also suggest that routine testing procedures are needed that
quantify early germination, and salinity and cold tolerance of rough bluegrass
cultivars/seed lots.
Acknowledgment
and Call for Assistance
We greatly appreciate the golf course superintendents that sent us seed
samples to conduct this research: Andy Apple, Bo Cooper, Scott Ferguson, John
Gay, Chuck Green, Richard Green, Julian Hopkins, Dicky McCarney, Alan Penland,
Kevin Taylor, Steve Woodring, and Steve Wright.
We will continue our work in this area. If you wish to help us, please send a quart zip-lock bag of each different rough bluegrass cultivar or seed lot you purchase and include the bag tags in the zip-lock. No blended seeds at this time, please. Mail to James J. Camberato, 2200 Pocket Rd., Florence, SC 29506. Include your name and address so we can send you an advanced copy of the results. Thanks for your help.