Collins and Pinch Chapter 7 and Conclusion



Chapter 7:  AIDS Cures and Lay Expertise

Background:

Clinical Trials:
Activism:
  
Community-based Trials:
Progress for AIDS Activists:
How did they make their voice heard:




Conclusion: the golem goes to work

Golem View of Expertise:
  • Expert evidence is easy to deconstruct
  • Expert evidence can quickly regain respect
  • Expertise should not be given unconditional respect
  • Expertise can be attained through various unorthodox routes
The Right Expectations:
  • The right expectations of science and technology must be met so that science and technology so that we can keep science and technology valuable
  • We can't expect perfection from science and technology otherwise failure will be the only result
  • There must be a middle road between failure and perfection in order for the technological world to make sense
  • Technology should be seen as "application of expertise in trying circumstances.